📚 Anti Diet Book Club-Week One

As the days continue to get darker and colder, I hope everyone is staying cozy andd maybe even starting to lean into holiday decor for some extra lights and festiveness.
Introduction
I am always a bit weary reading an introduction, I find they can be dry and a useless overview/outline of the book (which makes me more restless than anything to dig into the content already). This intro chapter is suprisingly good. I find really easy to read, and its one of the few authors whose self disclosures about her history with dieting and diet culture that is actually good. She avoids triggering numbers and unnessary detail on behaviours while also coming across as really relateable. She is also clearly describing herself as someone with a disordered eating/chronic dieting history and not an eating disorder given the relative ease she describes her ability to unintrench herself from harmful dieting/disordered eating behaviours. This in part could have been her genetic predisposition to thinness which also makes quitting dieting easier than for those that recover into larger bodies.... anyways... onto Chapter One!
Chapter One: The Roots of Diet Culture
I love that she starts this chapter with "diets culture is a slippery thing" - YES. It really REALLY is.
The chapter also starts with a fair bit of history on how cultures have viewed thinness and fatness, and where terms like "diet" originate. This information is interesting and also I think it can feel really disconnected from the "how" around body image distress and working towards acceptance when your body doesn't look or feel the way it has in the past or how you think it "should" look or feel (hint: cue internalized anti fat bias).
All that said, I do think its helpful that the author highlights how:
"The term diet, then, was bound up from the start with ideas about morality, restriction, the renunciation of pleasure, and the superiority of certain races" p21
I also thought this was worth highlighting/worth a re-read, especially given all the garbage on social media feigning constant concern for content creators "health" if they are living in a larger body:
Fatphobic beliefs pre-dated health arguments. In fact, through the end of the nineteenth century (as for most of human history) doctors held that larger bodies were healthier. p27
Read that one again. For most of human history, doctors held that larger bodies were healthier.
So, while this chapter doesn't necessarily help counter individual body distress in daily life & at holiday parties, I do think the historical context around where thin ideals & the diet industry comes from is important to learn about. Hopefully, it can also help ground individuals as they work to detach from deeply engrained anti fat bias and the desire for thinness.
I do love this quote from this chapter, and how much it highlights how the emphasis on how historically, women obtaining more human rights (to vote, to work outside the home, reproductive rights, or Nov3 in the US, an unprecedented number of women voted in during midterm elections), generally is equated by an extreme increase in the thin ideal. Essentially exactly what we have been seeing over the last few years with the rise of what I call, the Ozempic/GLP-1 era of diet culture.
A continuation of this conversation about how the increase in the pursuit of thinness for women has a political impact:
"[Pursuing thinness] serves to both distract women from their growing political power and to asuage the fears of people that dont want the old political system to change. Because if women are busy trying to shrink themselves, they wont have the time or energy to shake things up. Its hard smash the patriarchy on an empty stomach or with a head full of food and body concerns, and thats exactly the point of diet culture"
"Science and Medicine jump on the diet culture train" is also an important section in this chapter. Particularly because there was no scientific evidence to speak of at the time that this started (early 1900s)-- Doctors (who are humans like the rest of us) were influenced by the fad for thinness, not science, when they started giving weight loss advice for patients -- and this is still true today. Ugh. This is all about cultural anti fat bias, not actual science. This point cannot be repeated enough: the pursuit of thinness is not about health, and it never was.
I also like how this chapter gets into the absurdity and non medical/clinical/health nature
of BMI.
I think the key point is this:
The idea behind the BMI was conceived in 1832 by Belgian anthropologist and mathematician Adolphe Quetelet, but he didn't intend for it to be a health measure. Instead, it was simply an observation of how people's weight changed in proportion to height over their lifetime. aka. Its not a health meausre and yet... doctors are still using it everywhere. If you want to watch a little video on this, here is a good one: <BMI is BS> (just ignore her quick pitch about all things vegan at the end).
Also, I think it’s quite unsettling that Jenny Craig launched in 1983, the same year Karen Carpenter died of heart failure related to her eating disorder. There’s something particularly disturbing about the juxtaposition: at a time when the devastating physical and psychological consequences of eating disorders were being made painfully visible, the commercial diet industry was continuing to grow and capitalize on cultural fears around weight, food, and body size. It speaks to the deep disconnect between how society understands and responds to eating disorders and how readily it continues to promote and profit from restrictive eating and weight loss.
This chapter wraps up with a really great summary of the "Obesity Epidemic" - where it started & who funds it/benefits from it (pharmacutical companies) & is a worthwile reminder of just how bogus all the anti fat bias really is. In other words, companies continue to make billions of dollars off made up body/health fear mongering and its exceptionally harmful - always has been, always will be.
.... and with that, thats a wrap on Week ONE!
I am excited to keep re-reading with everyone ... see you next week for a Week2 recap (Ch2&3).




Comments